Page 1 of 1

Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Tue Nov 07, 2017 11:50 pm
by Tier4GEVO
CSX Q384-06 had a portion of its power plucked and placed onto a string of cars just west of Levan Road in Livonia, MI.
ImageConfusion by AmericanRailfan, on Flickr

CSX Q385-04 stops just short of the Lilley Road grade crossing in Plymouth, Michigan as it prepares to do hours and hours of work as it drops off and picks up new cars. Also note that TORC 996 is the third unit of the lashup.
ImageStopped For Hours by AmericanRailfan, on Flickr

A solo CSX GP38-2S prepares to enter the Toledo wye and head south.
ImageNo Cars by AmericanRailfan, on Flickr

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 10:07 am
by KVERBERK
Nice shots. Thanks for sharing

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 12:02 pm
by AARR
The GP38-2S looks like it has 3 radiator fans

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 12:29 pm
by Saturnalia
AARR wrote:The GP38-2S looks like it has 3 radiator fans
That's because it is a GP40-2 downrated to 2000hp

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 1:08 pm
by AARR
Does it still have a turbo charger?
Saturnalia wrote:
AARR wrote:The GP38-2S looks like it has 3 radiator fans
That's because it is a GP40-2 downrated to 2000hp

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 2:01 pm
by SD80MAC
AARR wrote:Does it still have a turbo charger?
Saturnalia wrote:
AARR wrote:The GP38-2S looks like it has 3 radiator fans
That's because it is a GP40-2 downrated to 2000hp
Yes. It’s just a GP40-2 de-tuned to 2000 HP. They didn’t change anything externally or even renumber them.

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 2:14 pm
by AARR
Thanks 80MAC and Saturn.
SD80MAC wrote:Does it still have a turbo charger?
The GP38-2S looks like it has 3 radiator fans
That's because it is a GP40-2 downrated to 2000hp
Yes. It’s just a GP40-2 de-tuned to 2000 HP. They didn’t change anything externally or even renumber them.

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 11:04 pm
by hoborich
Question. What is the reason for detuning a loco. Looks like they give up 1000 hp doing this.

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 9:43 am
by SD80MAC
Fuel efficiency I'm sure was the main concern, engine uses less fuel putting out 2,000 HP vs. 3,000. GP40-2s were also built to be relatively fast freight units, which is what they were generally used for until more modern 6 axles started displacing them in the 80s and 90s. Today they are used in local and yard service interchangeably with other Geeps, but they are not as well suited for switching as say a GP38-2. At 3,000 HP, a GP40-2 is more slippery at low speeds than a lower HP Geep. I can't tell you how many times I had a GP38-2/GP40-2 combo for switching and when pulling on a big cut of cars, the 40's wheels would break loose and spin while the 38 just dug in. Sort of the same story for the 6 axle versions, SD38s excelled at low speed lugging, which is why RRs like the EJ&E, B&LE and DMIR bought them over the SD40.

In short, the GP38-2S program was an attempt to make a GP40-2 more comparable to a GP38-2. How well this was accomplished, I don't really know, but they didn't convert many units, so I would guess marginal at best. CSX also derated some SD40-2s as well, calling them SD38-2Ss.

Re: Plymouth Area on 11/7/2017

Posted: Fri Nov 10, 2017 9:39 pm
by hoborich
Makes perfect sense. Thanks for the explanation.