Derailment in Mancelona

[NSSD70ACe]

Several cars on the ground in Mancelona. Local cops asking people to avoid the area “at all cost”.

https://www.mlive.com/news/2019/10/trai ... -cost.html

[PatAzo]

Sounds overly dramatic for derailed hoppers.

[NSSD70ACe]

Sounds overly dramatic for derailed hoppers.

Probably just wanted to stop people from congregating at the site. Probably just ended up bringing more out

[AARR]

There aren't that many people in Mancelona to begin with much less someone who cares about trains. Although maybe the officer was talking to KC

[Doktor No]

Seeings how US131 goes within a few yards of the area I will assume that's a wish that ain't gonna happen.
Sheriff probably thinks it is dangerous plastic beads...
And I hate MLive. "Disable your ad blocker"...ummm NO! It's there for a reason.

[kd_1014]

"A few box cars" LOL

[Standard Railfan]

Apparently the train was flying....

https://www.9and10news.com/2019/10/26/t ... tay-clear/

[KingsleyRailFan]

I drove out there today and took a few pictures from my moving car.

https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/ ... sp=sharing

Engines involved were SD40-2 382 (recently moved up here) and GP38-2 396. Neither engine was damaged. They are sitting a little bit aways from the wreckage. Most if not all of the hoppers involved are total losses. It looks like the rail collapsed from underneath the cars, where the units derailed the track is very low compared to the rest of the line. One road is completely blocked by the wreckage, and one hopper impaled itself into the ground, creating a large crater and a sledding hill.

[DLM]

Was the train northbound or southbound?

[KingsleyRailFan]

Was the train northbound or southbound?

North to Petoskey.

[hoborich]

Given the extent of damage to the ground and the cars, they must have been going somewhat fast, say 30MPH. They didn't just drop a couple trucks on the ground. The wreckage is fairly well strewed around and extensive. Also, we have had a lot of rain in the area lately. Was getting downright depressing!

[Doktor No]

Given the extent of damage to the ground and the cars, they must have been going somewhat fast, say 30MPH. They didn't just drop a couple trucks on the ground. The wreckage is fairly well strewed around and extensive. Also, we have had a lot of rain in the area lately. Was getting downright depressing!

Mass times speed squared. MxS2. Even going ten they will still scatter all over gods green earth. Weight and momentum are an amazing thing that Sir Issac understood. He just didn't have trains to play with. Cars and load come in at 286,000. times the amount of cars and square the speed. You get a really amazing number and crush force. And a big mess.

[Super Chief]

So the GLC sent an SD-40-2 across the Manistee River bridge? I'll bet that made her shake a little even at 10 mph. What's the weight difference between an SD and a GP-35? I know the Pennsy sent some large steam and diesels to Mackinaw City but a lot of years have passed on the infastructure since then and now. Also 1225 is prohibited from that bridge and the US-131 overpass. Since East Jordan foundry has a presence in Elmira as well as the cement place now is that why an SD-40 has been assigned to Cadillac? I thought with all the grain on the south end of the GLC those two units would stay down there?

[Saturnalia]

So the GLC sent an SD-40-2 across the Manistee River bridge? I'll bet that made her shake a little even at 10 mph. What's the weight difference between an SD and a GP-35? I know the Pennsy sent some large steam and diesels to Mackinaw City but a lot of years have passed on the infastructure since then and now. Also 1225 is prohibited from that bridge and the US-131 overpass. Since East Jordan foundry has a presence in Elmira as well as the cement place now is that why an SD-40 has been assigned to Cadillac? I thought with all the grain on the south end of the GLC those two units would stay down there?

I've only ever heard that the Manistee River Bridge was too light for the 1225, is the US131 part true?

Quickie comparison of relevant locomotive weights, and their weight per foot of locomotive:
GP35: 260,000 lbs; 4600 lbs/ft
SD40-2: 368,000 lbs; 5300 lbs/ft
ES44AC: 415,000 lbs; 5600 lbs/ft
PM 1225: 805,900 lbs; 8000 lbs/ft

Fun to note that SD40-2s get a continuous tractive effort of 82,100 lbf to the ES44AC's 166,000 lbf, even with only an additional 1400 hp and 47,000 lbs. The SD40-2 might be the engineer's engine, but GEVOs can really dig in and pull, once they load up, and unless they're throwing some errant diagnostic and unload themselves.

Compare that to the 1225, which only gets about 70,000 lbf. They're really freaking heavy but have larger drivers, no electronic traction control (obviously), and put only half their weight on the drivers compared with 100% for the three diesels here.

[Super Chief]

Thanks for the comparisons on tractive effort. That picture of a Baldwin centipede going thru Carp Lake on its way to Mackinaw still blows my mind. Anybody know whose handlung the clean-up of the cars? Hulcher or Corman is gonna make a motel up there very happy.

[AARR]

EJIW transloads coke from Cadillac so they don't get any traffic around Elmira other than possibly a few carloads of equipment.

Cement numbers seem below the 20-40 per week projections (that's a shocker isn't it ) with the exception of last year when the plywood plant in Grayling was under construction.

Since East Jordan foundry has a presence in Elmira as well as the cement place now is that why an SD-40 has been assigned to Cadillac?

[GP30M4216]

This article is well written and has some useful info:

https://www.record-eagle.com/news/local ... b4dd6.html

The tv footage from upnorthlive.com is priceless!

[Todd_F]

EJIW transloads coke from Cadillac so they don't get any traffic around Elmira other than possibly a few carloads of equipment.

Cement numbers seem below the 20-40 per week projections (that's a shocker isn't it ) with the exception of last year when the plywood plant in Grayling was under construction.

Since East Jordan foundry has a presence in Elmira as well as the cement place now is that why an SD-40 has been assigned to Cadillac?

I think the SD's are randomly assigned. Last spring I filmed GLC 329 (the ex ATSF SD45) between Caddy and Petoskey hauling 3 plastic pellets hoppers NBD and I think 7 total SBD (2 from Petoskey, 5 from Elmira). That tells me they didn't send the big SD up to Petoskey/Elmira to pull extra tonnage when one Geep would have sufficed.
Here is my video from that run.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q2Gp_kKmuxE&t=55s

[SD80MAC]

The SD40s typically stay south of Cadillac but there's nothing preventing them from running to Petoskey or even up to Traverse City, which they have done more than once since they got them.

[KingsleyRailFan]

Seems to me that they don't have a numbering ... program? and they just assign the numbers with numbers that either aren't in use or are ex-units. That seems to make the most sense but since they haven't received any new units recently I can't really proof this.